Reviews
Regular Review
vs. Lead TPC Review/Summary
- Each TPC member will be
the TPC lead for about 5 papers and will be a regular reviewer
for about 12-15 papers (including the ones for which he/she is
the TPC lead reviewer).
- For papers for which you
are the TPC lead, in your EDAS screen (after you login, select
"My TPCs" and INFOCOM 2014 from the
list of conferences), you will see both a link to "tpc" as well
as "review" under the "Type" column.
- For papers for which you
are a regular reviewer, you will only see the "review" link
under the "Type" column. First, you need to provide a review for
each of the papers in your list by using the "review" link and
filling out the review form by the Regular Review deadline. You
may delegate some regular reviews as described below (see
Delegation).
- After that there will be
an online discussion phase during which you can discuss with
other reviewers/TPC leads each of the papers that has been
assigned to you for review. The messages posted during the
online discussion will not be made available to the authors.
Please see below for instructions on how to participate in the
online discussion.
-
Once the discussion phase is over, as the TPC lead you will need to provide a summary of the discussions in the form of a TPC lead (meta) review. For this, please click on the "tpc" link under the "Type" column for your TPC lead papers and fill out the TPC summary form and choose one of four categories for each paper
- Accept
- Discuss
- Needs Additional
Review and
- Reject.
- Accept
- This TPC lead (meta)
review (TPC summary) needs to be completed by the TPC Summary
deadline. The TPC summary will not be made available to the
authors.